Monday, July 28, 2014

Not Quite 50 Thoughts on Fifty Shades of Gray (and why it's important for women, and in-turn, also great for men)

Pour yourself a glass of wine, or pop an ice cold beer and shoo the kids away -- this post is not child-friendly. Well obviously, we're going to be talking about Fifty Shades of Grey and everyone knows that means: S-E-X. Dirty, kinky, S-E-X.  And as usual, I'll probably use filthy language.

Earlier today, as I was perusing my facebook feed, I noticed a gentleman acquaintance had some pretty strong criticisms of FSG, and he was recommending people see a movie called "Secretary" instead. His criticisms were based around the "unbelievable and abusive/sick character of Christian Grey", and how he's not a real "Dominant". That the FSG enterprise is actually dangerous because it doesn't depict a "real" Dominant/Submissive relationship and that people (read: women) could get hurt by not understanding the proper rules and somehow finding themselves in relationships with abusive men that read the book or see the movie and want to take advantage of a woman's desires; that E.L. James clearly had no real working knowledge of a BDSM relationship and therefor her books should not be consulted by people seeking out such a relationship.
 

Like usual, I had something to say. . .

I wrote out a few paragraphs explaining why Fifty Shades of Grey was written in the first place, and how the resulting effect on thousands of women is a positive for womankind, no matter how "badly" the book reads. But when I went to click "post" I was informed he had deleted his original post. I don't know why he deleted it, but I had all this great stuff I'd said and no where to put it! I shared it with a good friend over private messaging and she asked me to blog it. . .  oh look! I do have somewhere to put it! Got your cocktail? You ready? 

You may or may not have heard that Fifty Shades of Grey was a Twilight fanfiction before it became it's own mega-selling, New York Times Bestseller: monster. It's true. It was. I know, I read it when Twilight fanfic was going hot n' juicy (excuse the pun) a few years ago, and back then it was called Master of the Universe with the nickname "50 Shades". Actually, FSG is not the ONLY Edward/Bella fanfic to have been published in the adult erotic fiction genre, just the most famous of them all -- to date. 

So in my post, that's now this blog, I told him that if you're wanting be angry at anyone for FSG and even it's resulting misdirection of BDSM-scene "rules", because it was written by a lady who had no actual prior practical knowledge of said-scene? Blame Stephanie Meyer, the woman who wrote Twilight! If it wasn't for her and her build-up of teenage angsty sex hormones between two virgins, over four books and thousands of fucking pages: and their final wedding night/honeymoon with a fade-to-black scene that made more than one woman throw that ridiculous and badly-written book "Breaking Dawn" against a wall. . . there would probably be no Fifty Shades of Grey! Yes, we all know that Breaking Dawn and the Twilight Series is a Young Adult genre, but c'mon now! You can't make us read so much ridiculous drama and angst and sexual frustration and Edward telling Bella over and over and over that she has to be a good little non-slutty-girlfriend and actually marry him if she wants the peen . . . and then give us NOTHING!?! You know when the movie has actually MORE SEX than the book? You got issues. Yep, it's Stephanie Meyer's flippin' fault! So if you want to blame anyone, blame HER!


Please, Edward, for the love of GOD, PLEASE DO ME!


But something magical happened when that crazy little fade-to-black scene in Breaking Dawn occurred. Thousands of grown women actually groaned in international unison over the worst case of female blue-balls the world had ever witnessed. . .  and then, as one could and should expect --  we women know how to take care of ourselves and each other -- and so we did

The world of Fan Fiction EXPLODED. Creative women with a wicked way with a pen wrote stories that filled the gaps, and colored the fade-to-black scene in beautiful, glorious and rightfully perverted: TECHNICOLOR! (Do you want to know what realllllllly happened on Isle Esme? Yeah I did, too. Go here and read for yourself! (warning:graphic sex) After you finish this blog, of course.) 

And if you're not familiar with the normal flow, the ebb and tide of fanfiction, let me briefly explain: It's not the same thing as going to a book store, or clicking "place order" on your computer, and having a book, one that's been finely edited by people paid to do it, and most importantly: finished, by the time you read it. Some fanfics are called "one shots", being just one chapter. Others take on the life of their own, and become not just one book, but enough words to fill two, three or even four books.  Hence the reason the FSG is a trilogy -- she had actually written all of that, week by week, releasing it to us Twiporn lovers one chapter at a time. It's a "slow burn" (another fanfic term, meaning the plot builds up slowly, over many chapters) of reading when you commit to reading a multi-chapter fanfic.  Part of the magic of the fanfiction slow burn of self-publishing is reading the comments, and suggestions, and the guesses of plot-twists and where it's all going, the criticisms . . . it's fun, like interactive reading. Who wouldn't love to talk to an author as you're reading their book chapter by chapter?

So this magic happened . . . and grown women read Twiporn, and wrote Twiporn, in amazing numbers, and exploded the world of fan fiction all because a Mormon wrote a teenage love story with all the feels and passions and excitement that most of us experienced in adolescence . . . and then cock-blocked us all so HARD that it's basically caused a sexual revolution amongst women.

Is Christopher Grey, an extremely wealthy, control-freak, 28-year-old who owns numerous companies and is a helicopter pilot by day, and a pervy guy (that has an extremely well-equipped BDSM dungeon in his home) who makes contracts with young, brown haired beauties to be utterly submissive and available to him at anytime, especially at night, because his real mother was a brown haired beauty of a crack whore who abused him, when he was then adopted by the Cullens Greys -- a believable character?

No more believable than the gorgeous, extremely strong, extremely wealthy, Volvo-driving, control-freak, 109-year-old virgin vampire that waited to find his mate to have sex, and makes her wait until their wedding night, refuses to drink the blood of humans, calls himself a vegetarian, and was adopted by the Cullen's. Oh and did I mention he fucking sparkles in the sun? Well that is whom Christian Grey is based on. Why would anyone expect him to be "believable"?

But let's go back to the most important point I made above: it's caused a sexual revolution amongst women.

This is my copy of Twilight, pretending to be Memoir of a Shark Fucker.

Right now. Today. It's still happening.

I came to the party fashionably late. I wasn't there since the beginning like some of my friends, but I was there as Fifty Shades was being written. Twiporn has kept me company when I was lonely. Helped me find myself when I thought I was lost. Helped me realize how oppressed and suppressed I was being treated, and reminded me that life is too damn short to be miserable or have bad sex. Entertained me through a lot of sleepless nights due to physical, chronic pain. I learned more than kinks, I learned about cave paintings in France, and impressive classical music conductors that aren't Mozart or Beethoven.

There was a time I would have been mortified to admitting I was reading Twilight. Much less Twiporn! But now I have to say I am proud . . . not because I want to advertise I like reading smut -- but because I was there when this revolution was in it's own breaking dawn (pun fully intended). I was there to see it all take shape into something bigger, to see the world change, and to watch women reclaim their sexuality. With every purchase of Fifty Shades of Grey, with every purchase of Wallbanger, with L.A.'s notorious kinky sex-shop, The Pleasure Chest, no longer being in dark paint and low lighting, to bright, and positive and heavily geared towards WOMEN. I was actually stoked to see entire lines of products geared towards fans of Fifty Shades (seriously, click that). Because it confirmed to me that what I believed to be true: is actually true. There is a sexual revolution occurring. 


 

At the time I snagged this photo, The Pleasure Chest was SOLD OUT of this kit!
Because THIS part of this whole creative-explosion of unbelievable male characters with utter-nutter control issues is: GOOD. No actually, it's great. Not because any woman wants an uber-control freak of a boyfriend/husband, sparkly or not. But because a LOT of women woke up, shook off the cobwebs we've been under in our "slut-shaming rape-culture" suggesting any woman that's raped and isn't a virgin must have deserved it. And even if they were a virgin they deserved it because you know, they have boobs and dare to look attractive and stuff. That we can't talk about our sexuality if we seriously want to be considered for equal pay for equal work. Because THIS SHIT happens when a woman is even considered a likely candidate for President of the United States. . . 

The 50's called, they want their misogynistic sign back!
   
We've been told we should be ashamed, consistently and we've been hiding our sexuality for far too long. So when at first Stephanie Meyer cock-blocked us, we got together, and we created, and we talked, and we perved-the-hell-out all over each other. We laughed, we connived, we conceived of every perversion we could think of in chat rooms and message boards and blogs. We shared so much -- not just the pervy, but the sexy, and the longings and desires and needs and wants. And hurts, and abuses and neglects. We had women donating to charities to help other women and in return they received whole entire chapters and/or outtakes from their favorite Twiporn stories. Married women returned to their marital beds with renewed vigor, and sadly some of them met very unwilling partners when they got there. But I'm happy to report that most husbands were awfully damn grateful their wives drank the Twilight/Twiporn kool-aid and wanted to read MORE. And to write more. And to desire even more at home. Women strove not only to really enjoy sex again, but had the courage to look into adventurous, or downright kinky, things that they might have long-been curious about, but were too terrified to even think about doing UNTIL the whole Twiporn revolution. We talked about sex in ways women hadn't done since the 70's or 80's. That's not just GREAT, that's HUGE. And even women who didn't drink the Twilight kool-aid, and didn't turn their iPhones and Blackberries into their own personal porn-hubs and literary peepshows -- well they heard whispers at work, and in mom's groups, and saw the morning news shows -- Fifty Shades of Grey was being published, and boy-O are you ladies, you corporate women working your asses off day and night and are still not being paid the same amount as your male co-workers. You housewives. You preschool teachers. You cat-ladies and cancer patients. You amputees and Little People. You service women far from home. You ladies who never even considered reading Twilight or weren't aware that there was an entire underground world of women saying "YES!" to sex. Yes, YOU, all of you: LADIES! Are you in for a TREAT!

Are these books well written? No. That's not the POINT. So what if they're a bit off? MOST women can understand the difference between real-life and fiction. And if they're going out and adventuring, they'll soon learn the rules and know their own limits. We sure the hell don't need men to tell us what those are. 

As for men with bad intentions or creepy personalities taking advantage of the situation?  Let's face it: when isn't there at least one bad amongst the good? There will consistently be cads that take advantage of situations, no matter what the situation is. But if one sparkly vampire cock-blocker of a book caused a world-wide sexual revolution amongst women? Go ladies! Get your sexy on! And if you want to adventure into the real world of BDSM? Read some actual books about proper rules/etiquette/limits . . . Wild Side Sex: The Book of Kink by Midori is a great start, especially involving emotional/trust issues one must address before involving themselves in the BDSM scene -- and I highly suggest that if you are new to the BDSM world, you DO read something more than Fifty Shades of Grey. FSG is fiction. The real scene, and the real-life emotions and trust-issues behind such play should be thoroughly explored before introducing your own heart, soul, mind and trust, least of all: your body to such play. Not to mention that of a partner you love. My friend was correct -- there are right ways and wrong ways to go about this. There is no Christian Grey out there to sweep you off your feet and chain you to a wall (I know, I'm so sorry ladies, but have you seen the official trailer for the Fifty Shades movie? SWOON!), and there is no vampire that's going to come along and sweep you into his shiny new Volvo and drive you off into the sunset where he'll sparkle all pretty for you . . . but there is a lot of ourselves to discover, to be loved, and cherished and enjoyed: and to be joyfully explored with a trusted partner.

Oh haiii you pervy ladies! You know I'd love to spank you, if only I were real . . .

Have fun with that! All of THAT! ENJOY YOURSELF!

 

And my most sincere thanks to Stephanie Meyer for inadvertently causing the revolution, and to E.L. James and all the other hard-working, fast-writing and talented ladies of fan fiction -- you fabulous pervs -- for picking up the reigns Stephanie dropped and leading all of us into a sexuality we can loudly and proudly proclaim as our own.


ADDITIONAL INFORMATION FOR THE CURIOUS:
For fun and crazy and totally perverted Twiporn fan fiction, I suggest MasenVixen and Stranger than Fiction at https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5634545/1/Stranger-Than-Fiction

Anything by Savage7289 https://www.fanfiction.net/u/2229847/Savage7289 ESPECIALLY Hide and Drink -- that fanfic had me from paragraph one! I mean seriously, a vampire acting like a vampire and kidnapping the one whose blood sings to him so he can drink her blood as he pleases? Yes please! 

And this one, this fic owns me and she hasn't updated in like TWO YEARS and I would appreciate any and all help from any new "fans" to pester this poor lady to please, for the love of all things vampire and actually interesting story line: FINISH THIS STORY!! (psssst she has a twitter account, go nag her!) The writer is Emmanuelle Nathan and the story is "This Buried Life". https://www.fanfiction.net/u/2077469/Emmanuelle-Nathan

I have more, of course, so drop me a comment if you want me to suggest any you might like!

8 comments:

  1. Love it, boo!
    I am posting this anonymously for reasons I am sure you understand :-)
    I loved MotU when it first came out. I was addicted to reading it. Then I started in on "Clipped Wings and Inked Armor"- more of the same as MotU, but with a bit more of the teenage angst still there. I really need to find the BDSM book you recommend to me, as well as listed here.
    You're fab and I love you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're the bestest of bestest Twiporn sharers and reviewers I have had over the years. We've had a lot of fun sharing smut, and talking smut, and most of all: trusting each other in order to openly and honestly talk about said-smut. I'm glad we have that relationship, and wise move on posting anonymously.

      And you seriously do have to help me nagging Emmanuelle Nathan to finish This Buried Life!

      Spanx you! I love you, too!

      Delete
  2. Thanks for the backgrounder on fanporn! This will surely be an eye-opener for some people!

    I (writer of the post that inspired your blog entry here, though mostly I was just adding commentary to a woman writer's longer article elsewhere) actually simply changed the privacy settings on my post, which made it look deleted to those not in the right group to see it any longer. It's still up there with comments and stuff. I'll see if mentioning you by name and letting FB link it will include you in it. I've also linked to your post here, from my thread.

    The vast bulk of the 'Secretary' vs. 'FSG' criticism (and 'FSG' criticism in general) isn't men telling women what their fantasies and limits should be! It's women writing out their own feelings on the matter, and some men with opinions on how this matters to them. In this case, it was a woman, Julia Pugachevsky, writing about why she preferred the former story to the latter, derivative one: http://www.buzzfeed.com/juliapugachevsky/reasons-to-watch-secretary-before-you-watch-fifty-shades
    It's not the only piece like this (and I'm not talking about ultra-feminist, sex-negative stuff, or religious moralizing stuff, either).

    Anyway, I didn't actually criticize Christian Grey's character as being unbelievable, and I don't think Pugachevsky did either. He's just kind of a douchebag who doesn't care much for consent or for anything but what he's getting out of it all. He's actually all too believable, as was Mickey Rourke's remarkably similar character in '9-1/2 Weeks', which 'FSG' cribs from quite a lot. The popularity of 'FSG' and its increasing mainstream acceptance is attracting to real-life BDSM too many asshat-dominants just like him, and ripe-for-misusing-submissives who think that's how a dominant should be. That's the main issue I have with 'FSG' (along with it being such a ripoff of 'Secretary', '9-1/2 Weeks', Anne Rice's "Sleeping Beauty" trilogy, and other prior art, going back to 'The Story of "O"'). I'm not alone among BDSM people on teh interwebs in these dislikes; a female acquaintance of mine has totally savaged 'FSG' on Facebook for being creepy, for misrepresenting and mis-presenting BDSM in almost every possible way, and sending dangerous messages. (I would link to that post, which is way more in-depth than mine was, but it's a friends-only one, so it wouldn't work for most of your readers. There are lots of similar critiques on webboards all over the place, though.)

    I did already know, vaguely, that 'FSG' had its origins in Twiporn fanfic, but that's not something I would hold against it very much. I've written (non-smutty) fanfic myself, and some of it could easily be developed into stand-alone fiction. I've also written erotica. I don't have any issue with the ideas that women find such stories hot and that there's a market for it, best written for by other women; it's just a shame that in this case it was one writer's not-well-researched, hyper-fantasy material instead of something more inspired and inspiring. I'm strongly reminded of the "being raped by Legolas wouldn't be rape, it would be SURPRISE SEX!" fantasies that fangirls post without thought on fandom forums, and which cause everyone else not experiencing the same fantasy to think "WTF did you just say?" That comes from the same place, the same make-believe playland, where 'FSG'-style erotica dwelling on non-consensual domination is taken by some as non-creepy only because it's just so totally fictional. If you will, it's the same kind of fiction as superhero comics or 'The Smurfs', in essence: There should be no room for genuine suspension of disbelief.

    (1/2)

    ReplyDelete
  3. (2/2)

    However, with erotica - which speaks to people's actual, deep, visceral fantasies, sometimes unconscious ones they have unresolved issues with - disbelief is often rapidly suspended no matter what crazy stuff is depicted, and some people tend to internalize it easily and firmly. This is the principal feminist objection to degrading, objectifying, male-audience, heterosexual porn, remember. If that objection were good for the gander, it'd be good for the goose, too. But I'm not convinced it is, any more than I see much evidence for the idea that playing 'Grand Theft Auto' a lot will actually *cause* delinquency. I'm not making anything like that argument here. Rather, the stories will appeal naturally to people (especially women, but only because of how it's been marketed and because the point-of-view character is female) who *already want* to explore being sexually and emotionally submissive, but will suggest poor ways of approaching this, including expectations that may be unnecessarily risky, expectations about what to look for in a dominant.

    The organized BDSM world has developed some best practices, out of collective experience, but they're not really "rules". It's possible to play safely without knowing them all, since many of them are just common sense and human respect. With experience, some can be dispensed with intentionally, after negotiation. The 'FSG' books seem to be *unaware* of a large number of them, or intentionally ignoring them as annoying hindrances to the plot. One of the fantastic things about 'Secretary' is that it has almost no connection to "the BDSM scene", in the sense of fetish clubs and people in leather outfits and rubber masks and stuff, yet the film still gets everything right when it comes to how such relationships and relating actually work (vs. fail painfully). The one hint I can recall is the spreader bar used to keep Gyllenhaal's character's hands far apart and basically useless, so that she had to do work with her mouth. Even that's something anyone can make with a dowel rod and two screw-eyes, not specialty equipment. Everything else about the film was about character and interaction and understanding.

    It's not that the 'FSG' books shouldn't have been written and the film not made, nor that they aren't "canonical" BDSM, nor that they have no value at all, nor that they are somehow, in and of themselves, dangerous; it's just that they're written from the perspective of and with the experience of a newbie. It's like a historical novel about Japan written by someone who's only fantasized about Japan and heard a little bit about Japanese history, and maybe knew some Japanese people and asked them some questions. All the while she was really working on a vampire novel. Heh.

    PS: I don't agree with the parenthetical in your characterization of my position as "people (read: women) could get hurt by not understanding", in that this has nothing to do with gender roles. Many men are submissive and women dominant (or "Dominant" as some scenesters like to capitalize it).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you did read my blog thoroughly, as I have read your comments, and did I realize I highly suggest people that REALLY want to explore the world of BDSM as a fantasy actually read proper rules on etiquette, and the emotional aspects -- specifically the preparedness of the mind/soul before the body -- of the "play" that they desire. I have linked not only one book on proper and real information, as well as an entire workshop on how to fulfill, properly, FSG fantasies. I've made it very clear that it's not well written, and it IS fiction, not source-material for actual BDSM play.

      I very well could have gone into BDSM, and explained it's the submissive that truly wields the power in such a relationship, but that wasn't what my post was about. It is about a sexual revolution that occurred because of a cock-blocking sparkly vampire teen book and all the erotica/porn that developed out of that. And in the way the world slowly rolls, it became a sexual revolution.

      I've noticed a few things since I've written this post -- that there is a ton of criticism on the feminist role in Fifty Shades, and most of the people criticizing are using their degrees in psychology to back their theories while freely admitting they haven't read the books. I read one this morning that says the whole story is really about Pedophilia, a psychologist proclaimed in 51 paragraphs about the book he hasn't read. It's interesting how many men are swooping in to rescue us poor females from the lies and degeneration sure to occur from this book.

      I don't know what's more annoying: people writing 51 paragraphs to assert lies about a stupid fiction they haven't read, or that the majority seem to be men trying to rescue us poor women from it. You said it perfectly above: "It's like a historical novel about Japan written by someone who's only fantasized about Japan and heard a little bit about Japanese history, and maybe knew some Japanese people and asked them some questions. All the while she was really working on a vampire novel. Heh." So are the men who are writing massive published articles criticizing the series they haven't actually read -- they just asked women about it!

      But you are dead-on correct with the Japanese book analogy as Fifty Shades was being written. Because E.L. James started a pervy little story she wanted to write, with no idea how much it would take off in the hallowed halls of Twiporn. So she starts and she has maybe 12 reviewers. The next chapter has 20 reviewers. The next chapter, 30 . . . and they're all giving input and ideas and making guesses where the story was going. She was able to pull off the slow-burn, write down her own Bella/Edward BDSM fantasies, interject ideas and desires of her readers. When I read it as an actual published book I thought "oh this is not so good", but reading it week by slow week, and with Edward and Bella as characters, and cliffies every time? It was FUN. Have you read Twilight? It's no feat of literary genius either, and sadly, Bella is far more annoying, self-degrading, depressing, desperate, whiny and weak than Anastasia ever was! So just consider the source now that you know it! Ha!

      1/1

      Delete
    2. (2/2 woops to above, that was supposed to be 1/2)

      And yes, I truly understand women have issues with it, too. The same women who would never condescend to read Twilight, and had no idea that a sexual revolution was happening in middle-America, in rural lands, the Moors of England, the Swiss Alps, that women living in the middle of nowhere were using the internet to learn about, and fulfill their ideas: about sex.

      A lot of the female critics of the book often liven in urban populations where they are not only more often exposed to sex, but to feminism, and fairer treatment of women. A lot of the female critics with experience in BDSM also live in places where they can actually join BDSM clubs and meet others easily with the same interests. New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, London, Berlin. It often doesn't occur to these urbanite ladies the actual source of these stories, or the interests. Because I can almost guarantee (meaning I am not going to research for a blog response) there's no S&M club in Truth or Consequences, NM, or Pink, OK, or Oakridge, AL.

      It's often easier to criticize from a position of power, or knowledge, or even availability to all the kink you could possibly want, even if you don't want it. Again, it's an insult to those who read it that they are not smart enough to know the difference between fact or fiction. They may not know where to find actual information if they weren't there at the breaking of the Twiporn explosion, and they may be new to 50 Shades. So it's important to provide resources before opining negatively ad nauseum about how bad the book is (not even argued). Especially to feel superior to fans of the series, because it's not a real BDSM relationship, and go on about that ad nauseum, too.

      And I'm sorry you disagree with my parenthetical characterization of your position, but that's exactly how it read, to me. And even your comments seem to read the same way, because they are cautionary tales about abusive men ready to pounce on the characters from badly written dominants, ready to abuse women that don't know what the actual role of a dominant is (as stated, it's the submissive that has all the power -- and that is something Fifty Shades of Grey sorely, sorely missed. In it Anastasia only became powerful to Christian because he fell in love. That's not the way real BDSM works, and anyone with any clinical knowledge -- or basic common sense -- knows this.).

      Women are becoming creative in the bedroom thanks to all of this smut, and that, to me, is the most important result of the whole thing, all the fanfic, the Twiporn, the FSG, Secretary. It's been a long time since Beauty's Punishment was published, and a realllllly long time since The Story of O. Erotic fiction was on a serious decline through the late 80's and the 90's and most of the first decade of the 2000's. But now women are talking about sex again!

      And of all this banter, the worth of books, the knowledge of writers . . . all that really matters is women are talking about sex again. All over the place, not just the cities. And that is what is IMPORTANT!

      I wasn't trying to attack you Stanton, I was just trying to give some background and insight about what the hell just happened in the dark and hallowed halls of the internet most sane men wouldn't even dare to tread! Hopefully I succeeded, and I apologize for offending you when it's not what you meant . . because over-all we are in agreement. And in that, I DID provide proper sources for those who are interested in a real BDSM relationship.

      Delete
  4. PS: I tried to read a little bit of 'Twilight' just to see what all the fuss was about, and couldn't stand it. The film was even worse. Half the point of the book is that Bella (despite her name, which means "Pretty") is a blank slate, an everygirl into whose shoes an enormous percentage of the young, female, mostly white, Western readership can step seamlessly. But they cast a strikingly attractive girl for the film role, but one whose *performance* is hollow and lifeless. In most scenes you could easily replace here with a cardboard cutout and no one would notice. She just stands there, expressionless and mouth-breathing. The character in the novel really feels and lives, a big formless vessel into which teenage girls pour their young sexual angst; we just don't know what she looks like. What they should have done is found someone not memorable looking but a solid actress, like a teenage version of Kathy Bates.

    Anyway, I really can't stand all this "young supernaturals in love" stuff. TV and movies are just overflowing with this formulaic crap. I'll give James kudos for realizing that her fanfic could be something more interesting with some reworking. Just wish she'd also done more research into how dominance and submission actually work between real people.

    ReplyDelete